A Comparison of the Effectiveness of Working Memory Training with Competitive Memory Training on the Psychological Symptoms and Cognitive Functions of People with Major Depressive Disorder

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

• Maryam Vatankhah ¹
• Sayed Mohammad Hossein Mousavi Nasab ²
• Abbas Rahmati ³

¹ Graduated from Master's degree, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran

² Associate Professor, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran

³ Professor, Faculty of Literature and Humanities, Shahid Bahonar University of Kerman, Kerman, Iran

10.22067/tpccp.2022.72652.1178

Abstract

Purpose: This research aimed to compare the effectiveness of working memory training with competitive memory training on the psychological symptoms and cognitive functions of patients with major depression.
Method: This study was performed on 60 patients with the major depressive disorder who were randomly divided into three groups: control, competitive memory training, and working memory training. The instruments used in this study included four computer tasks: asymmetry span, reading span, letter-number, dual n-back, three questionnaires: BECK Depression Inventory, Nolen -Hoeksema rumination Questionnaire, Rosenberg Self-Esteem Questionnaire, and the Wechsler intelligence Scale for Adult-Memory for Digit Span. Data were analyzed by using ANCOVA.
Findings: In all three experiments, performance during the training task significantly increased, but this performance gain did not transfer to the rumination. In working memory training group no positive effect of training on depression and self-esteem was found. But it did lead to improvements in the components of shifting, updating, and inhibition. Also, competitive memory training failed to improve cognitive functions in depressed individuals but led to improved depression and self-esteem. overall, results show that stand alone Working Memory tra
ining can not be effective on low self esteem and does not result in reduced rumination nor in reduced symptoms of major depression. Also, stand alone competitive memory training can not be effective on rumination, and cognitive functions in depressed maple Due to the different effectiveness of these two treatments and based on different therapeutic goals, one of these two treatments can be selected or used simultaneously with another treatment.

Keywords

• major depressive disorder
• competitive memory training
• working memory training

20.1001.1.22516352.1401.12.1.7.2

Main Subjects

• Clinical psychology

---

References

Addis, D. R., Wong, A. T., & Schacter, D. L. (2007). Remembering the past and imagining the future: common and distinct neural substrates during event construction and elaboration. Neuropsychologia, 45(7), 1363-1377.

Balci, S., Kwakman, M., & Boyer, B. (2020). Effectiveness of Competitive Memory Training (COMET) for low self-esteem in youth with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A randomized controlled pilot study. https:// doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/ae2y3

Beck, A. T. (1979). Cognitive therapy of depression: Guilford press.

Beck, A. T., Steer, R. A., & Brown, G. K. (1996). Beck depression inventory (BDI-II) (Vol. 10): Pearson.

Beloe, P., & Derakshan, N. (2020). Adaptive working memory training can reduce anxiety and depression vulnerability in adolescents. Developmental science, 23(4), e12831.

Blacker, K. J., Negoita, S., Ewen, J. B., & Courtney, S. M. (2017). N-back versus complex span working memory training. Journal of cognitive enhancement, 1(4), 434-454.

Brewin, C. R. (2006). Understanding cognitive behaviour therapy: A retrieval competition account. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 44(6), 765-784.

Camras, L. A., Holland, E. A., & Patterson, M. J. (1993). Facial expression. In M. Lewis & J. M. Haviland (Eds.), Handbook of emotions (pp. 199–208). The Guilford Press.

Daneman, M., & Carpenter, P. A. (1980). Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior, 19(4), 450-466.

De Lissnyder, E., Koster, E. H., Goubert, L., Onraedt, T., Vanderhasselt, M.-A., & De Raedt, R. (2012). Cognitive control moderates the association between stress and rumination. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 43(1), 519-525.

Ekkers, W., Korrelboom, K., Huijbrechts, I., Smits, N., Cuijpers, P., & van der Gaag, M. (2011). Competitive Memory Training for treating depression and rumination in depressed older adults: A randomized controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 49(10), 588-596.

Farahimanesh, S., Moradi, A., & Sadeghi, M. (2021). Autobiographical memory bias in cancer-related post traumatic stress disorder and the effectiveness of competitive memory training. Current Psychology, 1-9.

Haaga, D. A., Dyck, M. J., & Ernst, D. (1991). Empirical status of cognitive theory of depression. Psychological bulletin, 110(2), 215-236.

Hitchcock C, Werner-Seidler A, Blackwell SE, Dalgleish T. ) 2017.( Autobiographical episodic memory-based training for the treatment of mood, anxiety and stress-related disorders: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical psychology review. 52:92-107.

Holmes, E. A., Lang, T. J., & Shah, D. M. (2009). Developing interpretation bias modification as a "cognitive vaccine" for depressed mood: imagining positive events makes you feel better than thinking about them verbally. Journal Abnormal Psychology, 118(1), 76-88. doi:10.1037/a0012590

Jaeggi, S. M., Buschkuehl, M., Jonides, J., & Perrig, W. J. (2008). Improving fluid intelligence with training on working memory. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 105(19), 6829-6833.

Jaeggi, S. M., Studer-Luethi, B., Buschkuehl, M., Su, Y.-F., Jonides, J., & Perrig, W. J. (2010). The relationship between n-back performance and matrix reasoning—implications for training and transfer. Intelligence, 38(6), 625-635.

Joormann, J., & D'Avanzato, C. (2010). Emotion regulation in depression: Examining the role of cognitive processes: Cognition & Emotion Lecture at the 2009 ISRE Meeting. Cognition and Emotion, 24(6), 913-939.

Joormann, J., & Gotlib, I. H. (2010). Emotion regulation in depression: Relation to cognitive inhibition. Cognition and Emotion, 24(2), 281-298.

Kane, M. J., & Engle, R. W. (2002). The role of prefrontal cortex in working-memory capacity, executive attention, and general fluid intelligence: An individual-differences perspective. Psychonomic bulletin & review, 9(4), 637-671.

Kane, M. J., Hambrick, D. Z., Tuholski, S. W., Wilhelm, O., Payne, T. W., & Engle, R. W. (2004). The generality of working memory capacity: a latent-variable approach to verbal and visuospatial memory span and reasoning. Journal of experimental psychology: General, 133(2), 189-217.

Kazemeini, T. (2011). The Effectiveness of Cognitive-Behavioral Group Therapy in Improving College Students’ Self-esteem and Self-efficacy. Journal of Psychological Achievements, 18(1), 191-206.

Kerkhof, I., Vansteenwegen, D., Baeyens, F., & Hermans, D. (2011).Counterconditioning: An effective technique for changing conditioned preferences. Experimental psychology, 58(1), 31–38.

Korrelboom, K., Maarsingh, M., & Huijbrechts, I. (2012). Competitive Memory Training (COMET) for treating low self‐esteem in patients with depressive disorders: A randomized clinical trial. Depression and anxiety, 29(2), 102-110.

Korrelboom, K., Peeters, S., Blom, S., & Huijbrechts, I. (2014). Competitive memory training (COMET) for panic and applied relaxation (AR) are equally effective in the treatment of panic in panic-disordered patients. Journal of Contemporary Psychotherapy, 44(3), 183-190.

LeMoult, J., & Gotlib, I. H. (2019). Depression: A cognitive perspective. Clinical Psychology Review, 69, 51-66.

Luminet, O. (2004). 10 Measurement of depressive rumination and associated constructs. Depressive Rumination, 32(2),187-190.

Maramis, M. M., Mahajudin, M. S., & Khotib, J. (2021). Impaired cognitive flexibility and working memory precedes depression: a rat model to study depression. Neuropsychobiology, 80(3), 225-233.

Michl, L. C., McLaughlin, K. A., Shepherd, K., & Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2013). Rumination as a mechanism linking stressful life events to symptoms of depression and anxiety: longitudinal evidence in early adolescents and adults. Journal of abnormal psychology, 122(2), 339-352.

Miyake, A., & Shah, P. (1999). Models of working memory: Mechanisms of active maintenance and executive control: Cambridge University Press.

Monnart, A., Kornreich, C., Verbanck, P., & Campanella, S. (2016). Just swap out of negative vibes? Rumination and inhibition deficits in major depressive disorder: Data from event-related potentials studies. Frontiers in Psychology, 1019(7), 185-196.

Morrison, A. B., & Chein, J. M. (2011). Does working memory training work? The promise and challenges of enhancing cognition by training working memory. Psychonomic bulletin & review, 18(1), 46-60.

Nishimura, H., Hasegawa, A., Nishiguchi, Y., Tabuchi, R., Matsumoto, N., Masuyama, A.,... Tanno, Y. (2020). Relationship between trait rumination and imbalanced working memory: Analysis at the latent variable and individual task levels. Current Psychology, 1-12.

Onraedt, T., & Koster, E. H. (2014). Training working memory to reduce rumination. PloS one, 9(3), e90632.

Orth, U., Robins, R. W., Trzesniewski, K. H., Maes, J., & Schmitt, M. (2009). Low self-esteem is a risk factor for depressive symptoms from young adulthood to old age. Journal of abnormal psychology, 118(3), 472-478.

Platt, B., Waters, A. M., Schulte-Koerne, G., Engelmann, L., & Salemink, E. (2017). A review of cognitive biases in youth depression: attention, interpretation and memory. Cognition and Emotion, 31(3), 462-483.

Rice, F., Rawal, A., Riglin, L., Lewis, G., Lewis, G., & Dunsmuir, S. (2015). Examining reward-seeking, negative self-beliefs and over-general autobiographical memory as mechanisms of change in classroom prevention programs for adolescent depression. Journal of affective disorders, 186, 320-327.

Rogers, R. D., & Monsell, S. (1995). Costs of a predictible switch between simple cognitive tasks. Journal of experimental psychology: General, 124(2), 207-231.

Romano, M., Ma, R., Moscovitch, M., & Moscovitch, D. A. (2020). Autobiographical memory bias. In J. S. Abramowitz & S. M. Blakey (Eds.), Clinical handbook of fear and anxiety: Maintenance processes and treatment mechanisms (pp. 183–202). American Psychological Association

Rosenberg self-esteem scale (RSE). Acceptance and commitment Rosenberg, M. (1965).therapy. Measures package, 61(52), 18-20

Scott, J., Williams, J. M. G., Brittlebank, A., & Ferrier, I. N. (1995). The relationship between premorbid neuroticism, cognitive dysfunction and persistence of depression: a 1-year follow-up. Journal of affective disorders, 33(3), 167-172.

Sherrington, J., Hawton, K., Fagg, J., Andrew, B., & Smith, D. (2001). Outcome of women admitted to hospital for depressive illness: factors in the prognosis of severe depression. Psychological medicine, 31(1), 115-125.

Siegle, G. J., Ghinassi, F., & Thase, M. E. (2007). Neurobehavioral therapies in the 21st century: Summary of an emerging field and an extended example of cognitive control training for depression. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 31(2), 235-262.

Smith, J., Browning, M., Conen, S., Smallman, R., Buchbjerg, J., Larsen, K.,... Deakin, J. (2018). Vortioxetine reduces BOLD signal during performance of the N-back working memory task: a randomised neuroimaging trial in remitted depressed patients and healthy controls. Molecular psychiatry, 23(5), 1127-1133.

Söderlund, H., Moscovitch, M., Kumar, N., Daskalakis, Z. J., Flint, A., Herrmann, N., & Levine, B. (2014). Autobiographical episodic memory in major depressive disorder. Journal of abnormal psychology, 123(1), 51-60.

Staring, A., Van den Berg, D., Cath, D., Schoorl, M., Engelhard, I., & Korrelboom, C. (2016). Self-esteem treatment in anxiety: A randomized controlled crossover trial of Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) versus Competitive Memory Training (COMET) in patients with anxiety disorders. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 82, 11-20.

Steel, C., Korrelboom, K., Baksh, M. F., Kingdon, D., Simon, J., Wykes, T.,... van der Gaag, M. (2020). Positive memory training for the treatment of depression in schizophrenia: A randomised controlled trial. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 135, 103734.

Unsworth, N., & Engle, R. W. (2007). The nature of individual differences in working memory capacity: active maintenance in primary memory and controlled search from secondary memory. Psychological review, 114(1), 104-132.

Unsworth, N., Heitz, R. P., Schrock, J. C., & Engle, R. W. (2005). An automated version of the operation span task. Behavior research methods, 37(3), 498-505.

Van den Bergh, N., Hoorelbeke, K., De Raedt, R., & Koster, E. H. (2018). Remediation of depression-related cognitive impairment: cognitive control training as treatment augmentation. Expert review of neurotherapeutics, 18(12), 907-913.

Van Den Noort, M., Struys, E., Perriard, B., Staudte, H., Yeo, S., Lim, S., & Bosch, P. (2016). Schizophrenia and depression: The relation between sleep quality and working memory. Asian journal of psychiatry, 24, 73-78.

Vervaeke, J., Hoorelbeke, K., Baeken, C., Van Looy, J., & Koster, E. H. (2020). Transfer and motivation after cognitive control training for remitted depression in healthy sample. Journal of cognitive enhancement, 4(1), 49-61.

Wanmaker, S., Geraerts, E., & Franken, I. H. (2015). A working memory training to decrease rumination in depressed and anxious individuals: a double-blind randomized controlled trial. Journal of affective disorders, 175, 310-319.

Wante, L., Mueller, S. C., Cromheeke, S., & Braet, C. (2018). The impact of happy and angry faces on working memory in depressed adolescents. Journal of experimental child psychology, 169, 59-72.

Watkins, E., & Moulds, M. (2005). Distinct modes of ruminative self-focus: impact of abstract versus concrete rumination on problem solving in depression. Emotion, 5(3), 319-328. doi:10.1037/1528-3542.5.3.319

Watkins, E., & Teasdale, J. D. (2001). Rumination and overgeneral memory in depression: effects of self-focus and analytic thinking. Journal Abnormal Psychology, 110(2), 353-357.

Watkins, E., & Teasdale, J. D. (2004). Adaptive and maladaptive self-focus in depression. Journal of Affective Disorder, 82(1), 1-8. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2003.10.006

Watkins, E., Teasdale, J. D., & Williams, R. M. (2000). Decentring and distraction reduce overgeneral autobiographical memory in depression. Psychol Med, 30(4), 911-920.

Watkins, E. R. (2008). Constructive and unconstructive repetitive thought. Psychology Bullton, 134(2), 163-206. doi:10.1037/0033-2909.134.2.163

Williams, J. M. G., Barnhofer, T., Crane, C., Herman, D., Raes, F., Watkins, E., & Dalgleish, T. (2007). Autobiographical memory specificity and emotional disorder. Psychological bulletin, 133(1), 122-148.

Williams, J. M. G., Ellis, N. C., Tyers, C., Healy, H., Rose, G., & Macleod, A. K. (1996). The specificity of autobiographical memory and imageability of the future. Memory & cognition, 24(1), 116-125.